Legal in Modern, Legacy, Vintage, Commander.
About This Card
Nightmare is a rare creature from The List. Currently $0.32.
Released July 2021 as part of The List (Masters reprint set). Click through to The List for the full set's price index, top movers, and sealed-product EV.
Legal in Modern, Pioneer, Legacy, Vintage, Commander — cross-format demand provides multiple price support levels.
This printing is from The List, a reprint set — prices tend to be lower than original printings.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Nightmare a good MTG investment?
Nightmare is a rare from The List currently at $0.32. Legal in Modern, Pioneer, Legacy, Vintage, Commander. Check the SpellBook Score and reprint risk analysis on this page for a complete investment picture.
What is the price of Nightmare?
Nightmare from The List is currently $0.32 for nonfoil. SpellBook Finance tracks daily prices from TCGPlayer, Card Kingdom, eBay, and EU marketplaces — compare all sources on this page.
What is Nightmare's mana cost?
Nightmare's mana cost (casting cost) is 5B ({5}{B}). See Nightmare's full card text, color identity, format legality, and live prices on this page.
Should I buy Nightmare?
At $0.32, Nightmare is a rare with Legal in Modern, Pioneer, Legacy, Vintage, Commander.. Review the price history chart, supply signals, and reprint risk analysis on this page to make an informed decision.
Which buylist pays the most for Nightmare?
SpellBook compares Card Kingdom, CoolStuffInc, Star City Games, ABU Games, TCGPlayer, Manapool, and eBay. The Where to Sell section of this page surfaces today's highest net payout after fees and shipping, along with store credit bonuses when you want to trade up.
Is Nightmare good in Commander (EDH)?
Nightmare is ranked #13771 on EDHREC, making it a playable niche pick in Commander. Legal in Modern, Pioneer, Legacy, Vintage, Commander. See its price history and reprint risk on this page.
What formats is Nightmare legal in?
Nightmare is tournament-legal in Modern, Pioneer, Legacy, Vintage, Commander. Full format legality, price history, and reprint risk are on this page.
Other printings of Nightmare
- 30th Anniversary Edition #412 — $80.00
- Arena Beginner Set #54
- Welcome Deck 2017 #17 — $0.20
- Welcome Deck 2016 #8 — $0.15
- Magic Origins #282 — $0.14
- Magic 2015 #276 — $0.13
- Magic 2014 #108 — $0.19
- Magic 2010 #107 — $0.30
- Tenth Edition #164 — $0.47
- Ninth Edition #150★ — $4.06
- Eighth Edition #150 — $0.44
- Seventh Edition #150★ — $90.77
- Classic Sixth Edition #146 — $0.86
- Fifth Edition #184 — $1.19
Is Nightmare going up or down?
At $0.32, daily moves for Nightmare are tracked across TCGPlayer market, Card Kingdom, and eBay completed sales. Scroll up for the multi-source chart on this rare creature; direction matters more than yesterday's spot.
Is Nightmare worth buying?
Nightmare is currently priced at $0.32. Use the chart, recent sale comps, and SpellBook Score on this page to judge whether today's ask is a reasonable entry; fees and shipping can shift real cost 10 to 15%.
Nightmare reprint risk
This copy of Nightmare comes from a reprint set (The List), which already softened original-printing prices. The risk now is another reprint slot in a future Masters set or Commander deck; check the reprint risk score on this page for the latest signal.
Nightmare price history
SpellBook has tracked Nightmare since its 2021 release in The List across TCGPlayer, Card Kingdom, eBay completed sales, Cardmarket, and 13 other sources. It currently sits at #13771 on EDHREC, which shapes its long-run demand. The full multi-year chart and recent sale comps live above this section.
More from The List
- Ancient Tomb$127.41
- Rhystic Study$73.78
- Vampiric Tutor$67.74
- Anointed Procession$65.85
- Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth$64.47
- Esper Sentinel$63.72
- Demonic Tutor$61.79
- Shadowspear$60.57
- Phyrexian Altar$55.92
- Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx$53.55
- Minamo, School at Water's Edge
- Cavern of Souls$52.62