Recurring Nightmare

Recurring Nightmare

$85.30

Updated 8h ago
exorare·Enchantment·{2}{B}

Legal in Legacy, Vintage.

About This Card

Recurring Nightmare is a rare enchantment from Exodus. Currently $85.30.

Released June 1998 as part of Exodus (expansion set). Click through to Exodus for the full set's price index, top movers, and sealed-product EV.

Recurring Nightmare is on the Reserved List, meaning it will never be reprinted — permanently constrained supply makes it a blue-chip MTG asset.

Banned in Commander — price reflects demand from other formats rather than competitive play.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Recurring Nightmare a good MTG investment?

Recurring Nightmare is a rare from Exodus currently at $85.30. As a Reserved List card, it has permanently constrained supply. Legal in Legacy, Vintage. Check the SpellBook Score and reprint risk analysis on this page for a complete investment picture.

What is the price of Recurring Nightmare?

Recurring Nightmare from Exodus is currently $85.30 for nonfoil. SpellBook Finance tracks daily prices from TCGPlayer, Card Kingdom, eBay, and EU marketplaces — compare all sources on this page.

Should I buy Recurring Nightmare?

At $85.30, Recurring Nightmare is a rare with Legal in Legacy, Vintage.. Review the price history chart, supply signals, and reprint risk analysis on this page to make an informed decision.

Which buylist pays the most for Recurring Nightmare?

SpellBook compares Card Kingdom, CoolStuffInc, Star City Games, ABU Games, TCGPlayer, Manapool, and eBay. The Where to Sell section of this page surfaces today's highest net payout after fees and shipping, along with store credit bonuses when you want to trade up.

Other printings of Recurring Nightmare

Is Recurring Nightmare going up or down?

At $85.30, daily moves for Recurring Nightmare are tracked across TCGPlayer market, Card Kingdom, and eBay completed sales. Scroll up for the multi-source chart on this rare enchantment; direction matters more than yesterday's spot.

Is Recurring Nightmare worth buying?

Recurring Nightmare at $85.30 carries Reserved List scarcity, so the long-run floor is supply-supported. Compare 17 sources before pulling the trigger; fees and condition can swing real cost 10 to 15%.

Recurring Nightmare reprint risk

Recurring Nightmare is on the Reserved List, so Wizards of the Coast has committed to never reprinting it. Supply is permanently capped; the only downside risk is a counterfeit market, not a new printing.

Recurring Nightmare price history

SpellBook has tracked Recurring Nightmare since its 1998 release in Exodus across TCGPlayer, Card Kingdom, eBay completed sales, Cardmarket, and 13 other sources. The full multi-year chart and recent sale comps live above this section.

More from Exodus